Are Coaches Too Tough or are Athletes Too Sensitive?

Allie McDavitt 

Ohio State’s women’s hockey coach, Nate Handrahan, recently resigned “instead of being fired for violating the university’s sexual harassment, inappropriate conduct and retaliation” policies (Stein & Jones, 2015, para. 3). An investigation was done and witnesses reported Handrahan frequently “used sexually explicit or vulgar language during practices and games” (Stein & Jones, 2015, para. 7).  It was also reported that Handrahan belittled the players with many of them describing him as a “bully.”  The coaching staff described Handrahan’s coaching style as “direct,” “intense,” and “committed” and stated he did not threaten the players. Handrahan denied using inappropriate or sexually explicit language (Stein & Jones, 2015, para. 10). Ultimately, the university’s review found sufficient evidence of the coach’s policy violations. Before the investigation began, Handrahan had received written reprimand by the university after he missed the team bus to the airport and showed up to the airport “intoxicated and unprofessional” (Stein & Jones, 2015, para. 4).

            Handrahan completed his fourth season with the team. In his most recent performance review he received an overall “meets expectations” and was acknowledged for improving student welfare and academic success of the program. He was even awarded a raise in his salary.

            It is interesting that the university was very satisfied with his performance as a coach last May then not even a year later he is no longer working with the program at all. Some controversy is being brought up over his resignation. Many believe the athletes are being sensitive; bringing up the fact that the men’s hockey team probably hears much worse language during their practices. Collegiate athletics, especially division I universities, are extremely competitive. Coaches are going to be tough and push these athletes to their limits. But what is too far? At what point is being a “tough coach” considered unethical? Is it okay for coaches to use sexually explicit language when trying to get a point across? Is it okay for men’s teams to endure that treatment? Would the coach of a men’s team experience the same outcome in a similar situation?

References:

Stein, R & Jones, T. (2015, March 12). Complaints of sexual harassment prompt resignation of Ohio State’s women’s hockey coach. The Columbus Dispatch. Retrieved from http://buckeyextra.dispatch.com/content/stories/2015/03/12/0311-osu-resignation.html